Clallam County Sheriff Bill Benedict, center, talks with vaccination mandate protesters at the main entrance of the courthouse on Sept. 3. Photo by Keith Thorpe/Olympic Peninsula News Group

Clallam County Sheriff Bill Benedict, center, talks with vaccination mandate protesters at the main entrance of the courthouse on Sept. 3. Photo by Keith Thorpe/Olympic Peninsula News Group

Hundreds gather at Clallam Courthouse, seeking health officer

An estimated 200 to 300 anti-vaccine-mandate protesters rallied outside the Clallam County Courthouse on Friday morning, Sept. 3, before dozens entered the lobby, intent on confronting Dr. Allison Berry, the health officer for Clallam and Jefferson counties.

Law enforcement personnel blocked members of the crowd from proceeding down a hallway where a COVID-19 briefing was being held, upstairs to a courtroom that was in session, and downstairs to the basement, where the emergency operations center is located.

The meeting was not public and included Berry’s participation remotely via the county’s Granicus online meeting platform.

“The meeting was cut short once the crowd was attempting to make their way down the hall to the meeting room,” Brian King, Clallam County chief criminal deputy, said later Friday.

“There were a few folks who demanded to make their way into the meeting room.

“I did bring a couple of folks back so they could see Allison was not there. There wasn’t a whole lot of trust.”

Once they entered, men, women and children crowded into the first-floor area, where they continued to rally, shouting chants against Berry and demanding she be fired.

Her requirement for proof of COVID-19 vaccination for indoor restaurant and bar patrons in both counties went into effect Saturday. Those without prooof of vaccination or who do not want to provide proof can be seated outdoors or use takeout.

After about 45 minutes and several impromptu speeches by participants, a smaller version of the crowd slowly streamed out of the courthouse without incident, gathering to hear more speeches on the paved entryway.

Peaceful, insistent and sometimes angry before leaving, they challenged federal, state and local health officials’ justification for mandating the vaccine, now required statewide of most state, school, health care and child care employees.

They said that taking a vaccine is a personal choice.

The COVID-19 virus has infected Clallam County residents at a rate of 1,000 per 100,000 population.

Jerry Ludke, the former Port of Port Angeles airport manager, held a sign that said, “Unthankful for scary Dr. Berry,” about 30 minutes before protesters crowded into the courthouse. Berry’s former name while married was Unthank.

Ludke stood across Lincoln Street from the stately building, where hundreds of protesters crowded on the lawn and vehicles drove by, some drivers honking their support for the anti-vaccination-mandate cause.

“I’m out here to protest the vaccine mandate that is going into place tomorrow where people have to show their papers to go into restaurants and bars,” Ludke said.

“I think this is a free country, I think this is one more step towards tyranny, and people should have their freedom. They should be given health care information and people are smart enough enough to make their own decisions.”

Asked about what should be done when those decisions affect other people, he said the vaccine is available for almost anyone who is 12 and older.

“However, to require that of everybody when they still have questions about that, I just think that’s wrong,” Ludke said.

“Some of the questions are, for example, the government authorities have been completely downplaying natural immunity,” he said.

“If you’re healthy, if you’ve had COVID, there’s no need to show your passport. It’s a step in the wrong direction. We need to stop it now.”

The federal Centers for Disease Control said Aug. 6 that unvaccinated people who have had COVID-19 are more than twice as likely to get the coronavirus as those who are fully vaccinated (cdc.gov/media/releases).

Minutes later, a man shouted to the protesters through a megaphone, “To the front door, to the front door. We’re not here to hold signs.”

As the mass of people slowly moved to the Fourth Street entrance, to the blare of vehicle horns, a reporter wearing two masks for protection asked him for his name.

“If you took your masks off and you were a human, I would help you,” he said. No adults could be seen wearing masks.

A few seconds later, as the crowd kept moving, he identified himself as Anthony Banker, of Sequim, “a freedom fighter from Washington,” he said. “We will not be stopped.”

He exhorted the crowd, “they don’t want us to go through the front door.”

Banker urged the crowd to be peaceful.

“This is why we don’t have to have violence. This is why we don’t have to tear down buildings. This why we don’t have to light fires. Because we will show up in numbers with love in our hearts.”

Horns kept blaring as the protesters slowly streamed into the courthouse and walked toward the hallway.

As the crowd pressed toward the officers, a woman asked King about the COVID-19 briefing as he stood with officers blocking the passageway to the meeting.

King told her it was being held online.

“I’ll take it from here; I can help you out,” Sheriff Bill Benedict said, asking the crowd to stand 6 feet away so he could take his mask off.

“The mandate will be enforced in the following way,” he said. “The sheriff’s office is not going to arrest anyone for not having a vaccine card or not wearing a mask anywhere around.

“If you go into a business and refuse to wear a mask and they request it, or you refuse to show a vaccine card and they request it, they will ask you to leave. If you don’t leave, our deputies will be called, and you will be asked to leave, and if you don’t, we will arrest you, not for not having a mask.

“We will arrest you for trespass.

“It is private property. That private property owner, as you would expect, has the right within the law to choose who comes and who goes into their business,” he said.

A woman shouted, “Amen.”

About a half-dozen officers were bunched up in front of the hallway leading to the county commissioners’ offices and the commissioners hearing room.

One protester shouted “let us in” a few times while Benedict urged them to leave.

“You’re more than welcome to demonstrate outside,” he said. “Here, where we’re not following our own guidelines, guidelines for this capacity, I’m going to ask everyone to leave.

“We have business we need to conduct. It isn’t going to do any good here.

“I’ll even go outside to talk with you.”

He was answered with shouts of “We the people” and “Bring Dr. Berry outside,” and “We want Berry to answer our questions.” Others chanted her name or shouted, “Fire Berry.”

The crowd recited the Pledge of Allegiance twice, while some urged the crowd to remain peaceful and move outside.

“You can’t stop the citizens when they stand up and hold you accountable,” shouted one.

Some carried Donald Trump flags. One carried a sign that simply said “Nuremberg Code,” a set of 10 ethical principals for human experimentation that grew out of Nuremberg trials following World War II.

“This is child abuse, stop the mandate,” said one sign.

Another placard equated medical mandates with communism.

Several protesters also thanked the officers.

“They were direct,” Undersheriff Ron Cameron said, standing with his officers while the rally continued. “And they confronted me.”

Cameron said he had not discussed the increase in COVID cases with the protesters.

“That doesn’t seem to be the focus,” he said. “The focus is the order, not the reason for the order, but the order itself.”

Benedict returned from his visit with protesters outside the courthouse.

“It’s hard to argue with people that are feeling passionate, emotional, and it’s like, who can holler the loudest,” Benedict said.

“I basically said that the sheriff’s office is not enforcing the health officer’s mandate,” he said.

“And the reason we’re not enforcing it is that I don’t have the authority to enforce it. I did tell people that if they go into a business and refuse to wear a mask, we won’t make them leave.

“The sheriff’s office does not have the statutory authority to enforce health mandates.”

Benedict said if a restaurant does not comply with the vaccination mandate, it is up to Berry to “take note of it” and report it to the regulatory authority.

“They will come and investigate it, and if they decide to shut the restaurant down, it will be a civil process. It won’t involve me at all.”

He said that one out of every 30 county residents has had COVID-19, considering there have been about 2,500 cases.

“Hell, I’ve probably been exposed to it,” he said of being in the lobby among the unmasked protesters.

“But I’ve been vaccinated, and I’m comfortable.”

Jodie Wilkie, an organizer of the rally, could not attend the event because she had to work, she said.

Anti-vax concerns prompt courthouse closure

The Clallam County Courthouse was slated to be closed Tuesday, Sept. 7, until 1 p.m. for safety reasons until after county commissioners conduct a public comment period with Dr. Allison Berry, the public health officer for Clallam and Jefferson counties, who has received threats over her COVID-19 policies.

“I’m scared and stressed and committed to doing the right thing in spite of it,” she said Sept. 3 in a text message, a day before her mandate took effect that indoor restaurant and bar patrons in both counties must be vaccinated, a tipping point for many residents already upset over having to wear face masks.

Public comments will be taken between 10:30 a.m.-11:30 a.m. during the board’s regular meeting, which begins at 9 a.m., according to a public notice of the courthouse closure issued by the commissioners office late Friday afternoon.

Berry was reportedly to appear remotely, not in person.

The tight controls were prompted by the angry demonstration at the courthouse Friday morning (Sept. 3) by hundreds who trained their anger largely on Berry and to the vitriol directed at Berry and the commissioners, board chair Mark Ozias said.

Ozias said county leadership made the decision in consultation with the Sheriff’s Office.

The commissioners office also has received communications that have included threatening language “but not actually anything I would characterize as a threat,” he said.

“It’s different from one I’ve seen (toward) Dr. Berry.”

Having to close the courthouse over such concerns “is not a place I would ever hope we would be in our county,” he added.

The demonstration Friday included an impromptu hour-long rally in the courthouse lobby during which protesters were prevented by law enforcement officers from entering a meeting room where they thought Berry was conducting a COVID-19 briefing and from circulating inside the courthouse.

The meeting was cut short after protesters entered the courthouse.

The courthouse closure was announced at 4:30 p.m. Friday, about six hours after the demonstration.

In interviews on Sept. 3 and 4, Brian King, county chief criminal deputy, said the sheriff’s office received a report of people showing up Thursday, Sept. 2, at the address of a former residence of Berry’s apparently to confront her about coronavirus restrictions.

King said the group was nonviolent and left once they realized she was not there, and that there was no indication that criminal acts were committed.

That they showed up at what they thought was her home was still worrisome, he said.

“That would make anyone feel uneasy,” King said.

On Twitter, at SequimLibertyTree, @SequimT, Sequim Mayor William Armacost can be seen in a video walking up to more than a dozen protesters in a residential area.

“I’ve been working with my council,” he said. “We are working on a resolution, specifically dealing with this mandate, to keep our businesses afloat.”

In another video, dozens can be seen walking up to what appears to be a residence, many bearing American flags, before stopping and reciting the Pledge of Allegiance.

The Sheriff’s Office is patrolling Berry’s residence as a precaution and investigating threatening emails and communications that have been made against her.

“There have been a number of unpleasant communications, emails, etc. that she has received,” King said.

“Some are more threatening in nature than others, including those that appear there is an intent to do her bodily harm, so we are investigating those.

“There are some that are really pushing on that edge,” King added.

“We can see there is a whole lot of anger and hostility toward her, based on what we see in social media.”

The guidelines for Tuesday’s commissioners’ meeting will include limited occupancy in the board meeting room on the first floor that protesters wanted to enter Friday.

Speakers will be allowed into the room through the exterior doors on the south side of the courthouse, with no access available through the main entrance — which protesters streamed through en masse Friday.

Audio speakers will be placed outside the courthouse for those who cannot obtain access to the meeting room.

Ozias said Saturday that individual comments will be limited to three minutes.

“One of the things we are trying to prioritize is, we are anticipating a lot of people are going to want to share their thoughts with the board,” he said.

“We are also trying to create a plan that is going to allow for that to be done in a safe fashion so people’s voices can be heard and that part of the responsibility of public officials is to listen, particularly when people are upset. We are trying to make sure we facilitate that so there can be participation in our meeting.”

The Granicus live streaming of Tuesday’s meeting is available through clallam.net/features/meetings.html.

Those with court-related matters should go to the east side of the courthouse sheriff’s office entrance.

“Other steps are being taken to accommodate the expected numbers of citizens attending,” according to the notice.

Mask mandate protesters gather in front of the Clallam County Courthouse in Port Angeles on Sept. 3. Photo by Keith Thorpe/Olympic Peninsula News Group

Mask mandate protesters gather in front of the Clallam County Courthouse in Port Angeles on Sept. 3. Photo by Keith Thorpe/Olympic Peninsula News Group

Jerry Ludke holds a sign admonishing Dr. Allison Berry, the health officer for Clallam and Jefferson counties, during a rally against vaccine mandates on Sept. 3 in Port Angeles. Photo by Keith Thorpe/Olympic Peninsula News Group

Jerry Ludke holds a sign admonishing Dr. Allison Berry, the health officer for Clallam and Jefferson counties, during a rally against vaccine mandates on Sept. 3 in Port Angeles. Photo by Keith Thorpe/Olympic Peninsula News Group

More in News

Health officials urge caution over Thanksgiving holiday

No new cases reported in long-term care facilities on Peninsula

tsr
Elderly pedestrian killed in collision

An 83-year-old pedestrian who was talking to a driver stopped on a… Continue reading

Jefferson County resident dies of COVID-19

A Jefferson County resident has died from COVID-19, raising the total number… Continue reading

Sequim Police Blotter
Police Blotter — Nov. 24, 2021

The weekly police blotter includes incidents that occurred in the City of… Continue reading

First Federal foundation distributes $400K in grants to nonprofits

First Federal Community Foundation last week announced it has selected 17 nonprofit… Continue reading

How our legislators voted

Here’s a look at how area members of Congress voted over the… Continue reading

tsr
Club issues challenge for guessing first day of skiing

It’s anybody’s guess when the Hurricane Ridge Ski and Snowboard Area will… Continue reading

Teaser
Boys Girls Clubs exceed auction goal

Club alumni return to share success stories

TEASER
Sequim keeps Arbor Day tradition with park planting

The collection of beautiful plants and trees in Pioneer Memorial Park, 387… Continue reading

Most Read