Suspects arrested for allegedly stealing credit cards

Two suspects have been arrested for allegedly using stolen credit cards to purchase more than $2,600 in gift cards, the Clallam County Sheriff’s Office said.

Toby A. Berger, 38, of Sequim, and Jessica R. McFarland, 35, of Port Angeles each were booked into the Clallam County jail Friday for investigation of second-degree theft, Sheriff’s Sgt. Amy Bundy said.

Deputies alleged in court papers that Berger had taken a wallet from a man at a Port Angeles auto repair store and that he and McFarland used credit cards from the wallet to purchase gift cards from the Safeway east of Port Angeles.

Sgt. Eric Morris said Berger and McFarland purchased pre-paid Visa cards and gift cards from Applebee’s, Subway, Domino’s Pizza and Dairy Queen, according to the affidavit for probable cause.

Bundy said the alleged victim monitored his bank account and relayed the fraudulent transactions to deputies in real time.

Berger and McFarland were identified on video surveillance from the Safeway store east of the city, Bundy said.

They had purchased $2,600 worth in pre-paid Visa cards, an Amazon card and various gift cards, Bundy said.

“While deputies were investigating the theft, a citizen reported seeing the suspects throw the victim’s wallet out of a car,” Bundy said in a news release.

“Deputies retrieved the wallet and returned it to the victim, but the credit cards had been removed.”

Berger and McFarland were arrested in the Sequim area at about 8:10 p.m. Friday.

All but one of the gift cards purchased with the stolen credit cards were recovered, Bundy said.

“Both suspects confessed to having committed the crimes and were booked into Clallam County jail,” Bundy said.

“This investigation is ongoing and more criminal charges are likely to follow.”

Berger and McFarland each were released from jail on their personal recognizance Monday.

Clallam County Prosecuting Attorney Mark Nichols had requested $2,500 bail in each case.

Superior Court Judge Brian Coughenour scheduled arraignments in both cases for 9 a.m. Friday.

More in News

Clallam County Courthouse workers hang bunting on the front of the historic Port Angeles courthouse on Wednesday in honor of Independence Day. Photo by Keith Thorpe/Olympic Peninsula News Group
Special events to mark amended Fourth of July celebrations

The COVID-19 pandemic has scuttled plans for many July Fourth celebrations across… Continue reading

OMC commissioner questions per diem testing policy

The two Olympic Medical Center employees who tested positive for COVID-19 were… Continue reading

Health officers urge caution on Fourth; Clallam adds two COVID-19 cases

North Olympic Peninsula health officers are urging caution during the Fourth of… Continue reading

Shelter resident, Serenity House employee test positive

Two people at Serenity House of Clallam County tested positive for COVID-19… Continue reading

More COVID-19 cases in Clallam; none new in Jefferson

Four more Clallam County residents have been reported Wednesday as having tested… Continue reading

Early-morning fire damages East Sequim Bay Road home

An early morning fire Wednesday, July 1, has left a 4,000-square-foot home… Continue reading

With 4 new COVID-19 cases, Clallam County to remain in Phase 2

Clallam County will remain in Phase 2 of the state’s COVID-19 reopening… Continue reading

Clallam’s childcare crunch: Community leaders explore options

Expanding locations, training some of the options discussed

Deputies seeking suspects in Fish Hatchery Road home burglary

Clallam County deputies are seeking two persons in connection with a June… Continue reading

Most Read