Being Frank: Outdated wastewater facilities undermine water quality gains

Lorraine Loomis

Lorraine Loomis

We’ve seen some real progress over the past few years in efforts to prevent human waste from damaging the health of Puget Sound and the Washington coast. Still, we face a chronic problem with outdated wastewater treatment plants that undermine those gains even though we have the technology to address the problem right now.

After years of protest, Victoria, B.C., finally constructed a new wastewater treatment plant, ending its century-long practice of dumping millions of gallons of untreated sewage annually into the Strait of Juan de Fuca. Much of the sewage contained excess levels of nutrients, ammonia, fecal coliform bacteria, microplastics and toxins that harm all parts of Puget Sound and coastal ecosystems.

In another victory, we held off a move by the Trump administration and maritime industries to block implementation of a new no-discharge zone for human waste from boats in Puget Sound.

Under previous regulations, boats could dump partially treated sewage anywhere in the sound. Raw sewage could be flushed from boats three miles from shore. The new regulations prevent sewage from being dumped within a 2,300-square-mile area of Puget Sound, as well as lakes Union and Washington.

There’s even an app called Pumpout Nav to help boaters locate more than 200 pumpout stations in the zone.

These improvements are being undermined by inadequate wastewater treatment and persistent unintentional sewage releases from outdated Puget Sound wastewater treatment plants such as King County’s West Point water treatment plant.

Excess nutrients such as nitrogen in human waste fuel algae blooms that disrupt the food chain by removing oxygen from the water. Algae blooms result in fish kills and can harm people by making shellfish unsafe to eat. These nutrients also contribute to ocean acidification.

Sewage treatment plants in the Puget Sound region dump about 26 million pounds of nitrogen into the sound each year, according to the state Department of Ecology. Those numbers will continue to grow as more people move to the region.

The good news is that Ecology is requiring about 60 municipal wastewater treatment plants to reduce the amount of nitrogen they release. That’s in addition to a list of other improvements recommended by an advisory committee of tribes, state and federal agencies, wastewater utilities and environmental groups.

These necessary upgrades could take 10-15 years to complete.

That’s too long. Our population is only going to grow faster in the coming decades, making the problems worse and more costly to fix.

We already possess the technology to remove nutrients from wastewater entering Puget Sound. In fact, the Lacey/Olympia/Tumwater/Thurston County (LOTT) Clean Water Alliance has been doing it for years.

LOTT is an intergovernmental nonprofit organization that manages wastewater treatment for the three cities and county. It has the most stringent nutrient discharge limits of any wastewater treatment plant on Puget Sound. That’s because LOTT ratepayers invested millions to add nutrient removal at its Budd Inlet Treatment Plant about 20 years ago.

It’s been more than 30 years since the Ecology required municipalities to update wastewater treatment plant technology. Ecology more recently concluded that Puget Sound’s five largest treatment plants represent approximately two-thirds of municipal wastewater flows. Had these plants upgraded treatment when LOTT did, we would see improvement throughout the sound today.

Unfortunately, some cities around Puget Sound have been fighting Ecology’s efforts to restrict nutrients in Puget Sound. The city of Tacoma has sued the agency, claiming that new requirements would be too costly to implement.

That’s shortsighted because those costs are not going to get any lower and neither is the strain on wastewater infrastructure from the influx of newcomers in the region. We can pay now or pay a lot more later.

Right now, we are all paying with risks to our health. It doesn’t take much sewage to close shellfish harvest or to make people sick. Tribes pay a higher price because pollution robs us of our ability to exercise our treaty-reserved right to harvest fish and shellfish that are central to our economies and cultures.

There might be some hope in President Biden’s plan to rebuild our country’s degraded infrastructure, which includes funding to upgrade water treatment systems. It’s unclear if any of that funding will find its way to Puget Sound, so we need state, tribal and local governments, and others to demand it.

At the very least we should be following the federal Clean Water Act and Washington state laws that require the use of “all known, available and reasonable methods” to prevent water pollution. A first step would be to stop using Puget Sound as part of our sewer system.

Lorraine Loomis is chair of the Northwest Indian Fisheries Commission. See nwifc.org.

More in Opinion

Guest opinion: Courts, lawmakers shouldn’t make call on who’s media

Journalists of a certain age — those on the other side of… Continue reading

Bertha Cooper
Think About It: Newsworthy lies?

The big news in recent weeks is Facebook’s announcement that the former… Continue reading

Don Brunell
Guest opinon: Water has greenhouse gas problems

In our zest to quickly switch from gas-powered to battery-operated vehicles and… Continue reading

Kris Johnson is president of the Association of Washington Business, the state’s chamber of commerce and manufacturers association.
Guest opinion: Vaccines are a shot in the arm for small business

Early in the pandemic, signs of encouragement started appearing on theater marquees,… Continue reading

Don Brunell
Guest opinion: Land is wild card in Biden’s green gamble

Shortly after President Biden took office, he issued the sweeping executive order… Continue reading

USEPA Photo by Eric Vance. Public domain image
Being Frank: Outdated wastewater facilities undermine water quality gains

We’ve seen some real progress over the past few years in efforts… Continue reading

Bertha Cooper
Think About It: Wardrobe maleficence

It was my birthday. The husband and I took the train to… Continue reading

x
From the Back Nine: Bad juju

I had the good fortune to spend time at the Chito Beach… Continue reading

tsr
Guest opinion: Living, driving in the moment

As Washingtonians, we are a strong and resilient culture encompassed in constant… Continue reading

Crystal Linn
Aging Successfully: Senior citizens and mental health concerns

It is estimated that by the year 2050 there will be two… Continue reading

Don Brunell
Guest opinion: Ignoring China’s grip on critical metals production is not an option

China’s growing dominance of critical metals production and its vast stockpiles is… Continue reading

Don Brunell
Guest opinion: Build our future electricity supply around hydropower

Although New Zealand and Washington state are located a half-a-world apart, they… Continue reading