Being Frank: Tribes outraged by EPA move to roll back improved water quality standards

Treaty Indian tribes in western Washington state are outraged that the Environmental Protection Agency is advancing the agenda of a small group of industrial polluters to undermine public health, science and decades of hard work by rolling back the water quality standards that we have been implementing for almost three years.

The 2016 standards were supposed to make sure that seafood from Washington waters was safe for everyone to eat. EPA’s reversal no longer ensures that the human health criteria adequately protect Washington fish and shellfish consumers – including tribal members – from exposure to toxic pollutants.

Our health should not be unjustly jeopardized by increased levels of known dangerous pollutants like PCBs and dioxins that accumulate in the environment and cause real harm to people, orcas, salmon and the entire ecology of the region. PCBs and dioxins are the source of most public health warnings in our state regarding fish and shellfish consumption.

Industry wants to make this issue about select groups of people like tribes, Asian and Pacific Islanders and others who consume more fish and shellfish than other residents. The truth is that this issue is about all of us and everything we depend on.

Under the federal Clean Water Act, tribes and states – not the federal government – are responsible for setting water quality standards under their jurisdictions. EPA is allowed to revise existing standards only when they are deemed not strong enough. That’s not the case here because our current standards are among the most protective of human health in the nation.

That’s why we will fight this move with everything we have. We will stand with all 29 federally recognized tribes in Washington, the entire Democratic congressional delegation, the governor, attorney general’s office, environmental groups and many others who oppose EPA’s actions.

Tribes applaud Washington Attorney General Bob Ferguson for filing a lawsuit challenging EPA’s decision to roll back our water quality standards. “Trump’s EPA cannot change important water quality protections at the whim of industry interests. It’s not only disruptive to Washington’s environmental efforts over the past two years, it’s a clear violation of the Clean Water Act,” he said in announcing the lawsuit.

PCBs and dioxins are known carcinogens and we are going to have to deal with them one way or the other. The question is whether we want to do that when they’re still in the water or after they have entered our bodies and those of the fish, shellfish, orca and other species we are working so hard to protect.

Why are polluting industries trying to poison all of us? Simply for their short-term economic profit. In the process, EPA’s decisions threaten the integrity of the entire Washington state seafood economy.

Industry and EPA should be ashamed of their actions. It is unconscionable to knowingly allow more cancer-causing and other toxic chemicals to be released in our waters.

Lorraine Loomis is chair of the Northwest Indian Fisheries Commission. See nwifc.org.

More in Opinion

Don Brunell
Guest opinion: Colder weather could further chill restaurant recovery

Sunny summer weather helped restaurant owners and workers recover after they were… Continue reading

x
From the Back Nine: Creative sparks

The reason it is difficult to research facts about creative people is… Continue reading

Bertha Cooper
Think About It: Preying on the web

“O, what a tangled web we weave when first we practice to… Continue reading

Guest opinion: Coronavirus compounds recycling calamity

While the pandemic has dramatically improved air quality, it has been a headache for recyclers.

Water Column: Slow flow, part III (conclusion)

Compared to most indicators for 2020, the Water Year is closing relatively smoothly.

Think About It: Deep states

Conspiracy theories, reliable science stand in stark contrast under the Trump administration

Aging Successfully: Sequim’s outreach during pandemic, continued

In this month’s column, I wish to acknowledge more local organizations and… Continue reading

Guest opinion: Your Navy must be ready to respond

The U.S. Navy must continue activities to prepare sailors for dangerous or emergency missions

Guest opinion: Business, drones helping to restore scorched forestlands

Replanting millions of acres scorched by wildfires in our western woodlands will be a herculean task

Guest column: Lessons from COVID-19

Sequim resident reflects on lessons learned from a COVID-19 scare

Letters to the Editor — Sept. 16, 2020

Letters to the Editor, Sept. 16, 2020